The Truth About Bunion Surgery: What One Redditor’s Experience Can Teach Us

If you’re considering a Lapidus bunionectomy or any type of bunion correction surgery, understanding the real-world risks, recovery expectations, and the value of multiple medical opinions is critical. A recent Reddit post went viral when one user shared their painful journey through a failed Lapidus procedure—and how a second surgery turned things around.

This compelling personal story, combined with medical insight, offers essential lessons for anyone thinking about bunion surgery. Here’s what we can learn from their experience, backed by expert recommendations and practical tips.

---

🔍 What Went Wrong in the First Surgery?

Initial Procedure: Lapidus Bunionectomy

The Redditor underwent a Lapidus bunionectomy in July 2024 to correct what was described as a mild bunion. This procedure, commonly recommended for moderate to severe bunions, involves fusing the first metatarsal bone to a bone in the midfoot to realign the big toe joint.

Despite following post-op protocols—including limited weight-bearing, using a surgical boot, and attending follow-ups—the patient continued to suffer severe pain and complications.

Common Complications of Bunion Surgery

By six months post-operation, the patient had:

• Persistent nerve pain and “blood-rushing” sensations
• Swelling and a visible bump near the big and second toes
• A misaligned and elevated big toe, causing walking difficulty

Eventually, the first surgeon acknowledged an overcorrection, which is a known but serious risk of bunion surgery. According to the American Orthopaedic Foot & Ankle Society (AOFAS), potential complications of bunion surgery include nerve damage, stiffness, infection, and improper alignment.

The surgeon's recommendation? A toe fusion, which would permanently reduce toe flexibility and alter gait mechanics.

🩺 Expert Insight: “Overcorrection in bunion surgery, known as hallux varus, can be more disabling than the original bunion itself,” says Dr. Emily Splichal, DPM, a functional podiatrist and human movement specialist. “It’s critical to ensure the surgical plan matches the severity and biomechanics of the patient’s deformity.” ---

✨ The Power of a Second Opinion

Before consenting to a toe fusion, the patient sought a second opinion—a move that changed everything.

The new surgeon recommended repeating the Lapidus procedure, this time with better alignment and technique. The result?

• Immediate improvement in foot appearance
• Proper toe alignment
• Minimal nerve symptoms and a smoother, faster recovery

👉 Takeaway: A second opinion can uncover alternative treatments and prevent irreversible procedures.

🩺 Medical Recommendation: Always consult a second foot and ankle specialist—preferably a board-certified orthopedic surgeon or podiatrist—if the surgical outcome isn’t meeting your expectations. As per the American Podiatric Medical Association (APMA), individualized evaluation is key, especially in revision surgery. ---

🦶 Key Takeaways for Anyone Considering Bunion Surgery

1. Do Your Research

Understand what the procedure entails. The Lapidus bunionectomy is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It’s typically recommended for patients with joint instability or severe deformity. Milder bunions might be managed with less invasive procedures.

📚 Source: American College of Foot and Ankle Surgeons (ACFAS)

2. Choose the Right Surgeon

• Ask about their experience specifically with bunion surgeries.
• Look for board certification and hospital privileges.
• Request before-and-after photos and patient testimonials.

🛑 Red flag: If your surgeon isn't open to discussing complications or alternate approaches, seek another opinion.

3. Listen to Your Body

If pain, swelling, or numbness persists beyond the normal healing window (typically 6–12 weeks), speak up. Don’t assume it's “just part of recovery.”

4. Always Get a Second Opinion

Especially if your first surgeon is suggesting irreversible procedures like joint fusion. A fresh evaluation may reveal better options tailored to your anatomy and goals.

---

🧦 Non-Surgical Bunion Relief Options

Surgery isn’t always necessary. For mild to moderate bunions, conservative treatments may manage pain and slow progression:

• Supportive sleeves like the Orthopedic Bunion Pain Relief & Correction Sleeve help realign the toe and reduce discomfort during daily activities.
• Protection sleeves such as the Tailor's Bunion Bunionette Sleeves are designed to cushion bunionettes (small toe bunions).
• Moisturizing oils like Jamaica Black Castor Oil can help soothe irritated skin and reduce localized inflammation.

🩺 Tip: Combine these tools with proper footwear (wide toe boxes, arch support) and physical therapy for optimal results. ---

👣 Final Thoughts

This Redditor’s story is a cautionary tale—but also a hopeful one. While their first surgery led to complications, taking control of their care, seeking a second opinion, and advocating for their own health led to a better outcome.

Whether you're pursuing bunion surgery or exploring non-invasive options, remember:

• Educate yourself
• Choose your provider wisely
• Never hesitate to seek another opinion

---

✅ Key Takeaways

• 🔍 A Lapidus bunionectomy can be effective, but carries risks like overcorrection and nerve damage.
• 🩺 Always consult a second specialist if your post-op results are not what you expected.
• 👟 Non-surgical options like orthopedic sleeves and footwear changes can help manage symptoms.
• 📚 Trust reputable sources and board-certified providers when making surgical decisions.
• 🎯 Listen to your body—persistent pain is not normal and deserves attention.

---

🙋 Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is a Lapidus bunionectomy?

A Lapidus bunionectomy is a surgical procedure that corrects bunions by fusing the first metatarsal bone to the medial cuneiform. It's typically used for severe or unstable bunions.

How long does recovery take?

Recovery can take 6–12 weeks for initial healing and up to 6 months for full recovery. Weight-bearing is usually limited for the first 4–6 weeks.

Is nerve pain after bunion surgery normal?

Some nerve sensitivity is common, but persistent nerve pain or tingling should be evaluated. It may signal entrapment or damage.

When should I get a second opinion?

If your symptoms worsen, healing seems stalled, or the recommended treatment feels extreme (e.g., joint fusion), consult another foot and ankle specialist.

---